Assess housing need and site alternatives together so a development proposal responds to a defined problem rather than a convenient parcel. A useful assessment explains who needs the homes, what type of provision is relevant and why the proposed location merits further work.
The evidence and formal tests depend on the local planning system. Use a general comparison framework while confirming the requirements of the authority responsible for the decision.
Define the need before selecting a site
Describe the households or groups the project aims to serve, the geographic area and the time horizon. Review available evidence on housing conditions, demand, affordability and existing or committed supply. Record source dates and distinguish observations from projections.
A headline population forecast does not by itself define the required dwelling mix. State the assumptions that connect the evidence to the programme.
Set criteria for housing need and site alternatives
Agree the objectives and constraints before ranking locations. Relevant criteria may include access to services, land control, infrastructure, existing use, environmental conditions and delivery prospects. Use consistent definitions so the comparison does not favour a preferred site through changing rules.
Record which criteria are mandatory, which express a policy preference and which are provisional. Keep any weighting visible and explain who agreed it.
Screen the existing supply and candidate locations
Review how existing buildings, committed projects and potential sites could respond to the brief. Avoid counting the same capacity twice. Identify where a location depends on redevelopment, access rights, infrastructure investment or a planning change.
Use authoritative building records, cadastral context and current planning information for the screen. The site information pack helps organise sources and unresolved questions.
Compare spatial capacity with 3D scenarios
For shortlisted sites, use a common measurement basis and explicit assumptions. Test a small number of arrangements rather than presenting a maximum theoretical envelope as a deliverable plan. Report housing capacity with land allocation, access and public-space implications.
The parametric massing workflow can help explain how changed heights, footprints or use assumptions affect the comparison.
Include delivery and distribution
Assess the evidence needed for infrastructure, technical feasibility, land availability and funding. Explain which groups benefit, which may experience disruption and how the proposal connects to existing communities. A large capacity figure does not remove an unresolved delivery dependency.
Keep technical findings, financial assumptions and policy judgements separate enough that reviewers can inspect each one. Refer material questions to the relevant specialist or authority.
Explain the preferred direction
Show the alternatives considered, the reason for the choice and the main uncertainties. Keep rejected options in the record with their rationale. State what evidence or decision would be needed before the project can move to its next stage.
3D Cityplanner can support the spatial comparison and communication of development choices. Use it to make assumptions understandable alongside the wider evidence, rather than treating the model as proof of need or approval.
Frequently asked questions
Does demonstrated need mean every proposed site is suitable?
No. Need, location, design and delivery each require appropriate evidence.
What should the assessment leave behind?
A clear brief, consistent criteria, comparable site options, source references and an explanation of the remaining decisions.
